Convened in the summer of 2006 in response to member criticism of the publication of an ad for CIA employment on the official AAA job site, the purpose of the Commission is to advise the Executive Board and the Association by providing information and/or recommendations on the following: (1) The varied roles that practitioners and scholars of anthropology currently assume within intelligence and national security entities (2) The state of AAA’s existing guidelines and guidance on the involvement of anthropologists in intelligence/national security-related activities (3) The key ethical, methodological, and practical/political challenges faced by the discipline and the AAA in its current and future engagement in intelligence/national security.
Given important unresolved issues and continuing concerns—such as the controversial Human Terrain System which continues to receive substantial national and international press coverage―CEAUSSIC’s work has been extended for two more years up through 2009. This builds on conclusions of its initial Report, submitted to the AAA’s Executive Board in November of 2007 (Final Report). This work will give attention to information-gathering to provide better understanding of the forms of anthropological engagement, kinds of disciplinary practice, work environments, institutional contexts, as well as the ethical implications of this work, within the military, security and intelligence arenas. As a research body, CEAUSSIC’s purpose is to provide a helpful and grounded framework for the informed evaluation and discussion of these various matters by the anthropological community.
CEAUSSIC is further organized into smaller work groups, each addressing a key topic. These are dedicated to the following specific concerns: (1) Situational Ethics and Review of other Ethics Codes and Precedents, (2) Secrecy and Disclosure, (3) Free and Informed Consent, (4) The Prohibition to “Do no Harm,” (5) Disseminating Research Results and Proprietary Data, (6) Characteristics of Anthropological Practice, (7) the Army’s Human Terrain System Program, and (8) Institutional Environments and Types of Employment. As a key topic of concern, each will be given sustained attention, variously combining limited ethnographic research, policy and institutional analysis, interviews, and through compiling representative cases. The work of each group will be coordinated with the goals and activities of CEAUSSIC as a whole.
As part of this basic mandate, CEAUSSIC is also tasked with the following activities: (1) Supporting and advising the AAA’s Executive Board on the discipline’s involvement with military, security and intelligence, (2) Dialogue, education, outreach and coordination with different constituencies composing the AAA membership and other organizations and groups about the discipline’s interests and concerns regarding these matters, as this is appropriate, and (3) Providing written and other products and outcomes addressing these issues which effectively describe key concerns, provide case examples, and highlight accompanying ethical implications of each, (4) And the production of an ethics Casebook compiled and annotated with the purpose of providing an illustrative range of questions and issues raised by the possibilities of anthropological engagement with the military, security and intelligence communities (see call).
Duration of the Commission: 3 years.
Commission Reports to: AAA Executive Board.
Membership: 12 Individuals including the chair, a liaison to the EB, and the AAA President as an ex-officio member
Product: Final Report
Meetings and Schedule: Phone conferences, and in person meetings as needed
Staff Liaison and Contact Information: Damon Dozier, Director of Public Affairs, American Anthropological Association, 2200 Wilson Blvd., Suite 600, Arlington, VA 22201, (o) 703/528-1902, (f) 703/528-3546, firstname.lastname@example.org
Ethics Casebook - Call for Submissions:
CEAUSSIC is asking its colleagues in anthropology and related disciplines for summaries of illustrative cases that explore intersections among the ethical, methodological, and theoretical aspects of work in, around, and for the national security state, including public and private institutions, in and outside academia. To contribute, please go here.
Proposal for Examination of the Human Terrain System
The AAA Executive Board has requested that CEAUSSIC gather information regarding the Human Terrain System. For more information, click here.
CEAUSSIC in the News
AAA Blog Posts
- "Moving Forward with the CEAUSSIC Ethics Casebook: What is the Casebook, and Why Now?" ~ Laura McNamara (January 27, 2010)
- "Origin Story and Grande Finale" ~ George Marcus (December 7, 2009)
- "Reflections on the Soon-to-be Released CEAUSSIC Report" ~ Jean Jackson (November 30, 2007)
- "Why not Mandate Ethics Education for Professional Training of Anthropologists?" ~ Carolyn Fluehr-Lobban (October 13, 2009)
- "Anthropological Engagements with Military and Intelligence Agencies: Ethics, Politics, and ongoing Discourse" ~ David Price (September 11, 2009)
- "Anthropology, Public Health and National Security--An Eyewitness Account of Colliding Worlds" ~ Monica Schoch-Spana (August 21, 2009)
- "Mars Turns to Minerva: Thoughts on Archaeology, the Military, and Collegial Discourse" ~ Laurie W. Rush (July 21, 2009)
- "Anthropologists and Analysts" ~ Robert Albro (June 8, 2009)
Anthropology News - Ad Hoc Commission Articles
- "Ethics and Dual-Identity Professionals" ~ Robert Albro (Sept. 2009, pgs. 17-18)
- "Guiding Principles over Enforceable Standards" ~ Carolyn Fluehr-Lobban (Sept. 2009, pgs. 8-9)
- "Crafting an Ethics Casebook" ~ Robert Albro (Jan. 2009, pg. 13)
- "CEAUSSIC Phase Two" ~ Robert Albro (Nov. 2008, pg. 17)
- "Anthropology and the Military" ~ Dinah Winnick (Feb. 2008, pgs. 18-19)
- "Expanding and Engaging Anthropologies" ~ Alan Goodman (Jan. 2008, pgs. 21-22)
- "Reflecting Back on a Year of Debate With the Ad Hoc Commission" ~ Kerry Fosher, interview (Oct. 2007, pgs. 3-4)
- "Ad Hoc Commission Headlines at the Watson Institute" ~ Paul Nuti (May 2007, pgs. 24-25)
- "Commission at Halfway Point" ~ James Peacock (May 2007, pgs. 19-20)
- "Anthropology and the Wages of Secrecy" ~ David Price (Mar. 2007, pgs. 6-7)
- "Open Source Experiments: What They Show About the Analyst's Frustrations in Intelligence Communities" ~ Christopher Kelty & George Marcus (Feb. 2007, pgs. 3-4)
- "Anthropology's Terms of Engagement with Security" ~ Robert Albro (Jan. 2007, pgs. 20-21)
- "Ethical Challenges for Anthropological Engagement" ~ Carolyn Fluehr-Lobban & Monica Heller (Jan. 2007, pg. 4)
- "Does Anthropology Need a Hearing Aid?" ~ Robert Albro (Nov. 2006, pg. 5)
- "Where Are the Anthropologists?" ~ Laura McNamara (Oct. 2006, pg. 13)
- "Ad Hoc Commission Commences" ~ Paul Nuti (Sept. 2006, pgs. 25-26)
- "Engaging With National Security" ~ Alan Goodman (Feb. 2006, pg. 63)